// sources

Every number, and where it comes from.

Everything quantitative on batchd.no is listed here with the document behind it. Regulation and court outcomes link to the primary source. Where a figure is an estimate or an assumption, it says so.

Last verified September 27, 2026

The stakes

01

More than 3,900 products from over 200 companies were recalled in the 2008 to 2009 PCA outbreak.

Peanut Outlook: Impacts of the 2008-09 Foodborne Illness Outbreak Linked to Salmonella in Peanuts
USDA Economic Research Service, Wittenberger and Dohlman · February 2010

ERS cites CDC and FDA. The final figure of 3,918 products is reported by trade press; the site uses ERS's "more than 3,900".

02

The industry put its losses at up to $1B.

Peanut industry: Recall price tag $1 billion
NBC News, reporting Georgia Peanut Commission testimony to the House Small Business Committee · March 2009

An estimate given to Congress while the outbreak was ongoing, not an audited total. The site therefore says "up to".

03

PCA's CEO was sentenced to 28 years in prison.

Former Peanut Company President Receives Largest Criminal Sentence in Food Safety Case
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 21 September 2015

Stewart Parnell: 336 months. Michael Parnell: 240 months. See source 22 for the appeals.

04

Smucker booked $52.3M in reserves within weeks and flagged a further $125M the next fiscal year, after insurance.

The J.M. Smucker Co. Announces Fiscal Year 2022 Fourth Quarter Results (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1)
US Securities and Exchange Commission, EDGAR · 7 June 2022

The company's own words to investors. An insurance receivable of $49.8M was recorded at the same time.

06

CDC told consumers, restaurants and retailers not to eat, serve or sell any romaine lettuce, days before Thanksgiving 2018.

CDC Food Safety Alert: E. coli Outbreak Linked to Romaine Lettuce
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, media statement · 20 November 2018
07

Damage from the 2018 romaine advisory was estimated at $276M to $343M, most of it on shippers and processors.

Economic impacts of food safety incidents in a modern supply chain: E. coli in the romaine lettuce industry
Spalding, Sexton, Goodhue and Kiesel, American Journal of Agricultural Economics · 2022

Peer reviewed, built on price and sales data from a major leafy-greens processor.

Summary in Food Safety Magazine
30

147 people infected in 28 states, 33 deaths and one miscarriage from listeria in Jensen Farms cantaloupes.

Multistate Outbreak of Listeriosis Linked to Whole Cantaloupes from Jensen Farms, Colorado
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, final update · 27 August 2012
31

The owners of Jensen Farms pleaded guilty to six counts and were sentenced to five years' probation, six months of home detention and $150,000 each in restitution.

Statements Regarding the Sentencing of Eric and Ryan Jensen
US Attorney's Office, District of Colorado · 28 January 2014
32

Ten people hospitalized in four states and three deaths. Blue Bell recalled all of its products on April 20, 2015.

2015 Outbreak of Listeria Infections Linked to Blue Bell Creameries Products
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention · 2015

The criminal case is under source 21.

33

About 1,939 reported illnesses linked to eggs from Wright County Egg and Hillandale Farms in 2010.

Investigation Update: Multistate Outbreak of Human Salmonella Enteritidis Infections Associated with Shell Eggs
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention · 2 December 2010
34

More than 500 million eggs were involved in the nationwide recall.

Salmonella Enteritidis Outbreak in Shell Eggs
US Food and Drug Administration, outbreak page, archived copy · August 2010

FDA's original page has been taken down. The link is the Internet Archive copy. Wright County Egg alone accounted for 380 million.

35

Quality Egg paid $6.8M. Its owner and his son were each sentenced to three months in prison and a $100,000 fine.

Quality Egg, Company Owner and Top Executive Sentenced in Connection with Distribution of Adulterated Eggs
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 13 April 2015

A $6.79M company fine plus restitution and forfeiture. The son was the chief operating officer.

The ROI calculator

05

The 2022 Jif recall covered 49 SKUs.

The J. M. Smucker Co. Issues Voluntary Recall of Select Jif Products Sold in the U.S. for Potential Salmonella Contamination
US Food and Drug Administration, recall notice · 20 May 2022

49 product lines, each with its own UPC, in FDA's table.

08

FDA estimates $575M a year in avoided overly broad recalls.

Requirements for Additional Traceability Records for Certain Foods, final rule, 87 FR 70910
Federal Register, US Food and Drug Administration · 21 November 2022

The primary estimate in the regulatory impact analysis at a 7% discount rate. The range is $233M to $1.8B.

09

27% of participants could show a complete lot code source at every tracking event. Collaboration compressed what might have taken 48 to 96 hours into a single day.

Traceability Readiness Tabletop Exercises Final Report
US Food and Drug Administration · June 2026

15 firms, six scenarios, exercises held 9 March to 1 April 2026. 40% captured the lot code correctly at every tracking event.

10

FDA logged 1,617 food recall enforcement reports in 2025, 773 of them Class I.

openFDA Food Enforcement Reports API
US Food and Drug Administration, openFDA · Queried 20 September 2026

One report per product per firm, not a count of distinct recall events. USDA meat and poultry are not included.

11

Median spillover cost from one overly broad recall: $3.0M to $72.7M per producer and $0.1M to $3.1M per non-restaurant retailer, by firm size.

Costs of Overly Broad Recalls
Ackerley et al., Journal of Food Protection · 2025

Structured expert elicitation with romaine 2018 as the reference case. Distributors: $0.1M to $2.3M. Restaurants: $0.04M to $1.1M.

12

The 2026 Botticelli recall: 16,200 units from one lot, Class I.

openFDA enforcement report H-1273-2026
US Food and Drug Administration, openFDA · Initiated 17 July 2026
FDA recall notice
13

Recalled infant formula was found in over 175 store locations in 36 states, one for over three weeks. FDA sent warning letters to four major retailers, Walmart among them.

FDA Takes Action to Improve Recall Effectiveness Following Infant Botulism Outbreak Investigation
US Food and Drug Administration, press announcement · 15 December 2025

The Walmart letter records the associates' explanations: lack of awareness of the recall, confusion over which lots were affected, and failure to remove all product. It cites section 301(c).

Warning letter to Walmart
16

Suppliers bear all costs of a removal action and are charged an administrative fee per market plus labor.

Supplier Recall Policy
US Foods, supplier documentation · Current as of September 2026

One public example of a common contractual practice. Amounts are not stated, which is why the calculator's chargeback figure is an assumption you set yourself.

Penalties, fees and liability

17

Distributing adulterated food is a misdemeanor with no intent required: up to one year in prison. With intent to defraud, or a second offense, up to three years.

21 U.S. Code § 333, Penalties
Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School · Current text

Corporate fines in the cases below are set under the alternative fines statute, 18 U.S.C. § 3571, which allows up to twice the gain or loss.

18

Kerry Inc. pleaded guilty and paid $19.228M over the 2018 Honey Smacks salmonella outbreak.

Kerry Inc. Pleads Guilty and Agrees to Pay $19.228 Million in Connection with Insanitary Plant Conditions
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 3 February 2023
19

Chipotle paid a $25M criminal fine and entered a deferred prosecution agreement.

Chipotle Mexican Grill Agrees to Pay $25 Million Fine and Enter a Deferred Prosecution Agreement
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 21 April 2020

More than 1,100 people fell ill in outbreaks between 2015 and 2018.

20

ConAgra Grocery Products pleaded guilty and paid $11.2M over salmonella in Peter Pan peanut butter.

ConAgra Subsidiary Agrees to Enter Guilty Plea in Connection with 2006 through 2007 Outbreak of Salmonella Poisoning
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 20 May 2015

An $8M criminal fine plus $3.2M in forfeiture.

21

Blue Bell pleaded guilty and paid $19.35M. Its former CEO later pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor.

Blue Bell Creameries Agrees to Plead Guilty and Pay $19.35 Million for Ice Cream Listeria Contamination
US Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs · 1 May 2020

$17.25M in fine and forfeiture plus a $2.1M civil settlement. Paul Kruse pleaded guilty to one misdemeanor in 2023 after a jury deadlocked on the fraud counts.

DOJ case page for Kruse
22

The Parnell brothers' final appeals were denied in August 2025.

Parnell v. United States, Nos. 22-13907 and 23-11786
US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · 11 August 2025

The district court's denial of the § 2255 motions was affirmed.

23

FDA charges $354 an hour with domestic travel for work triggered by a firm's failure to comply with a recall order, from October 1, 2026.

FSMA Domestic and Foreign Facility Reinspection, Recall, and Importer Reinspection Fee Rates for Fiscal Year 2027
Federal Register, US Food and Drug Administration · 30 July 2026

Base rate $325, $414 with foreign travel. Billable work includes audit checks, status-report reviews, inspections, travel and monitoring product disposition (FD&C Act section 743).

24

Boar's Head expanded its recall by about 7 million pounds. The outbreak caused 61 illnesses, 60 hospitalizations and 10 deaths across 19 states.

Boar's Head Provisions Co. Expands Recall for Ready-To-Eat Meat and Poultry Products
USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service · 30 July 2024
CDC outbreak investigation
25

The Jarratt plant was closed from July 2024 and reopened on February 3, 2026.

Boar's Head reopens Jarratt plant tied to deadly listeria outbreak
Virginia Business · 5 February 2026

Production stopped in July 2024; the closure was made formal in September 2024.

Why now and compliance

14

FSMA 204 requires traceability records to be kept for two years and delivered to FDA within 24 hours of a request, as a sortable spreadsheet in an outbreak or recall.

FSMA Final Rule on Requirements for Additional Traceability Records for Certain Foods
US Food and Drug Administration · Current as of September 2026

The rule text is 21 CFR part 1, subpart S. The 24-hour requirement is § 1.1455.

15

The FSMA 204 compliance date is July 20, 2028.

Requirements for Additional Traceability Records for Certain Foods: Compliance Date Extension, proposed rule
Federal Register, US Food and Drug Administration · 7 August 2025

The 30-month extension from January 20, 2026 is proposed, not final. Congress has separately barred enforcement before the same date, and FDA has said it will follow that.

26

GS1 Sunrise 2027: the retail transition from 1D to 2D barcodes at point of sale.

What is GS1 Sunrise 2027?
GS1 US · Current as of September 2026
27

A firm removing a product it believes is violative should immediately notify the appropriate FDA district office.

21 CFR § 7.46, Firm-initiated recall
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · Current text
28

Sesame is the ninth major food allergen and must be labeled from January 1, 2023.

The FASTER Act: Sesame Is the Ninth Major Food Allergen
US Food and Drug Administration · Current as of September 2026
29

FSMA 204 requires identifying both the supplier you received from and the customers you supplied to (one step back, one step forward).

21 CFR Part 1, Subpart S, Additional Traceability Records for Certain Foods
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · Current text

The traceability plan is § 1.1315. Receiving and shipping requirements are §§ 1.1340 and 1.1345.

36

A recalling firm sends FDA periodic recall status reports, generally every 2 to 4 weeks: how many consignees were notified and how, how many responded and what they had on hand, how many did not respond, how much product was returned or accounted for, and the results of effectiveness checks.

21 CFR § 7.53, Recall status reports
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · Current text

Reports stop when FDA terminates the recall. Firms provide the information at the start of a recall under § 7.46 (source 27).

Model assumptions in the ROI calculator

These figures have no external source. They are assumptions, labelled as such on the page, and each one can be adjusted or challenged.

Note: Batch'd stores traceability data, structures audit logs and guides the response workflow. Notification to regulators, adherence to retention deadlines and legal responsibility remain with the operator. Nothing on this page is legal, financial or compliance advice.